For decades, the starter home has been the first step into homeownership for many Americans—an affordable, modestly sized home that helps buyers build equity and transition to larger homes later.

But that stepping stone is quickly disappearing.

With the 2025 buying season approaching, first-time buyers are facing a challenging market, with fewer affordable options and rising home prices. If you're working with first-time buyers, understanding the realities of today’s market and helping them navigate it effectively is more important than ever.

Why Starter Homes Are Disappearing

The number of smaller, entry-level homes on the market has declined significantly over the years. In 1982, nearly 40% of new homes were under 1,400 square feet. Today, that number has shrunk to just 9%.

What’s driving the decline?

• Restrictive Zoning Laws: Local regulations are making it harder and more expensive for builders to construct smaller homes. These zoning laws increase costs and limit development options.

• High Construction Costs: The price of labor and materials has increased by 50% over the last decade, while the cost of land has skyrocketed even higher.

• Builder Priorities: Developers are focusing on high-end homes where profit margins are larger, making it less feasible to build smaller, more affordable options.

• Low Inventory: With many homeowners holding onto their low mortgage rates, fewer existing homes are available, driving up demand and prices for those that do hit the market.

What This Means for First-Time Buyers

Today’s market presents unique challenges for first-time homebuyers, who are now older than ever—with the median age rising to 38 years old compared to 29 in 1981. In addition, they’re competing against a record number of all-cash buyers, making affordability and competition even tougher.

But despite these challenges, opportunities still exist for those who are informed and prepared.

5 Tips for Helping First-Time Buyers Navigate This Market

1. Set Realistic Expectations
   Many first-time buyers come into the process with expectations based on their parents’ experiences or outdated market conditions. Educate them on today’s realities and help them focus on what’s attainable within their budget.

2. Explore Alternative Housing Options
   Encourage buyers to consider townhomes, condos, or older homes that may need some updates. These options often provide a more affordable entry point into homeownership.

3. Get Creative with Financing
   Work with mortgage professionals to explore creative financing solutions, such as first-time buyer assistance programs, grants, or lower down payment options. Understanding all available options can make homeownership more accessible.

4. Focus on Long-Term Investment
   While the idea of a "starter home" may be shifting, encourage buyers to look at their first home as a long-term investment that can build equity over time—helping them move up the property ladder later.

5. Stay Competitive with Strong Offers
   In a market where all-cash buyers dominate, it's essential to help clients submit strong, competitive offers. This includes being pre-approved, flexible on contingencies, and prepared to act quickly when a good opportunity arises.

Conclusion: Adapting to the New Normal

The days of easily accessible, affordable starter homes may be fading, but with the right approach and guidance, first-time buyers can still achieve their dream of homeownership. As a real estate professional, your role in setting expectations, providing solutions, and offering support has never been more valuable.

Want to stay ahead of the market and provide your clients with the best strategies?

👉 Join my Solo Agent Accountability Coaching Program to learn how to guide clients through challenging market conditions and grow your business with confidence.